I need guidance on my journey back into faith. I was raised strictly Roman Catholic, and there was corruption within my church community. I am bisexual, and I have many friends who are generally part of the LGBT+ community, and my church was not accepting of that. I was shamed into the closet. It was a driving factor in my leaving, but it wasn't the only thing. I'm scientifically minded, and catholics have a pretty strict guideline on evolution and lack thereof. I didn't agree with what I was being taught in Sunday school. I didn't like that I had to wear skirts and dresses only to church, never pants. All around, catholicism just wasn't for me, and my faith in general disappeared for about a decade.
As for why I'm getting back into my faith, I was told I was infertile, and I have been blessed with a healthy pregnancy and birth of my baby girl. When I first suspected I was pregnant, I prayed for the first time in over ten years. I've prayed a few times since then, and every time, I am moved to tears. There's a large wave of Catholic guilt for abandoning my faith. I don't feel worthy of forgiveness, though I know He will forgive. It's not quite comfortable yet, but somehow, it also feels like coming home.
If anyone has been on a similar journey, I would love to hear your stories and get advice on how to be more comfortable returning to faith. (I currently identify as a nondenominational Christian).
The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.
Learn more about our guidelines.
First, kudos to you for being brave enough to share your heart with us! I’m praying for you as a fellow sister in Jesus Christ.
I don’t have all the answers for you, but as I read your post, the name of Jackie Hill Perry came to mind: https://jackiehillperry.com/#about
She wrote “Gay Girl, Good God,” which was a book that deeply moved me. She’s very open about the kinds of struggles she faced in coming to faith, including many of the ones you’ve mentioned. It blessed me so much to read her testimony.
Hope this helps! Feel free to message me anytime if you have further questions or thoughts - I identify as a nondenominational Christian as well.

thank you so much❤️ I will look into her work!

Hey sister, my heart goes out to you for the rejection and hurt you e gone through from the people in the church, it’s not what God wants. I was raised in a different denomination that wasn’t super strict in interpreting the Bible in a specific way but encouraged a relationship and obedience to God and I’ve found this to be much more supportive than those who say if you don’t believe the “right” thing then you’re out. I’ve read “After Doubt” which is a good book about asking questions of God. And then I find Ravi Zacharias’s lecture on truth really freeing for me too, his apologetics are really solid.

Are you looking to return to the Christian faith? If so, I’d just say to be mindful, because if you’re returning to Him, it will come with a lifestyle and conviction change. It can be difficult and hard at times. I have many friends in the LGB+ community myself. It has driven wedges between some of us and others, we simply respect that we have a different mindset and hold to very different beliefs and keep moving forward as friends. :) So it can depend on community as well, how hard it is. Because to be Christian means to be Christ-like and to be Christ-like means to live honoring his Word & living like he did. So just make sure you’re returning to your faith for the right reasons and not for just emotions and you should do fine. :)

I've come back to Catholicism after leaving in 7th grade. You may want to try a different parish and see if it was a parish issue or a Catholicism issue. Feel free to send me a message 😊

As for evolution, the Church itself actually holds no official opinion