Letting a baby cry….

My MIL has told me a couple of times that I need to start leaving my baby (5 months old) to cry on their own so she learns to soothe herself and I can have more time to myself. This doesn’t feel natural to do to me at all as my natural response is to comfort her. but she says I may create future attachment problems by going to baby straight away & letting her contact nap when she wants to. Do you think this is true? Do you let your baby cry it out? Any opinions x

Read more on Peanut

The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.

Learn more about our guidelines.
Add a comment
Avatar

Please don’t take this advice 😢 it’s actually been proven it’s damaging to babies brains to leave them to cry, they won’t learn to self soothe this way, they will jut eventually stop crying because they learn that no one is coming. Contact naps and comforting them is more than okay, it helps the bond.

There are only this little for such a sort amount of time too and one day they may not want this many cuddle ect, for me it’s teaching them him mummy will always be there whenever he needs me and can come to me anytime no matter what. Xx

Avatar

thanks! She meant well but she mentioned I might give her separation anxiety by always being there. I suddntly felt like I was doing something wrong - so this is reassuring!

She is such a happy baby, she just loves feeling close and being held a lot in the daytime & contact naps, but has worked for us so far. Exactly I want her to know she can come to me for comfort. Parenting is so confusing because everyone tells you different things & you constantly want to do everything the right way 😭 x

Avatar

Babies will get separation anxiety any way hun!

I defo get what you mean! Just go with your gut and what feels right to you. My Nan kept trying to tell me that I my son should be upstairs on his own in his cot for naps and that I shouldn’t pick him up right away when he wakes, safe to say I ignored her. Older people need to remember that times have changed and Will constantly be changing. X

Avatar

Totally agree with chrissy. We are naturally designed to keep our babies close at all times, as they're so helpless compared to other mammals. You won't damage her, you'll actually create a very healthy attachment which is what children need to feel safe and develop well mentally.

Keep cuddling that bub ❤️

Avatar

I was told if fed and cleaned and your putting them down to sleep at night let them cry for around 3 minutes then do a check and cuddle, repeat adding a minute each time as long as you know needs have been met doing it this way helped get into a proper sleep routine, it was really hard at first but within a week we had a great sleep routine, but I completely get all babies are different what works for one won’t necessarily for others, it’s you baby don’t let anyone tell you what to do

Avatar

I never let my kids cry it out......there was always a reason. And I was right. Both my kids are now 11 and 15, no issues no attachment issues either. You won't damage her at all. At the end of the day she is your baby, do what you feel is necessary xx

Avatar

My MIL keeps saying I'm spoiling my LO by picking her up when she cries or holding her to sleep. She's even said that LO shouldn't be putting hands or toys in her mouth. She was promptly told where to go with her so called advice. X

Read more on Peanut

Trending

in our community

Any September 2025 babies crawling yet

My little one isn’t crawling yet but he loves tummy time

Avatar

7

19

Did you know this was a thing?

Didn’t know this existed! I’m actually not breastfeeding 2nd time round (though wish I did) after a bad experience with my 1st baby. But this is something I 100% needed 1st time round.

Avatar

9

3

How do you dry your 🐱?

Looking to settle a debate with husband, he is teaching our girls to dry themselves after they shower, i am teaching them to dry to a certain point on the inside but not between

Avatar

19

Screeching baby

I have twin boys, 5months.

One is very quiet

The other... is like a pterodactyl who screeches when bored, tired, hungry, as soon as he wake up to be held etc...
This habit has only just started!

Has anyone else experienced this and how long did it last?
So far it has been about 5 days 😭😭😭😭

Avatar

11

Circumcision, please help

I know it can be a really sensitive topic, but I feel really underinformed about whether I should choose to circumcise or not if we end up having a boy.
For context: we are very non-religious, but I worry about the stigma of being non-circumcised when he would start to get interested in dating, navigating cleaning it and the risk of infection especially as he gets older and navigating potty training at daycare and stuff. I also worry about the increased risk of penile cancer. But then I also hate the thought of making my baby go through a major surgery unnecessarily and would prefer for them to make the choice when they are older if they choose to get circumcised.

How did you make your choice? Does anyone regret their choice?

Avatar

20

Joie Signature Parcel LX lightweight stroller

Has anyone got this stroller? Up until now we have used our mamas and papas ocarro and we love it. However we are going on holiday in June and looking at a lightweight stroller to take with us. I'm not bothered if it fits in overheard locker, I would rather have decent wheels on the stroller and this one does have slightly bigger wheels than most travel strollers we have seen. Has anyone used this stroller abroad or got any other recommendations? TIA x

Avatar

1

8

Read more on Peanut