Purée or BLW

Hi mamas, I’ve been weaning my 6m for about 3 weeks now and have been mainly giving him 1 Ella’s kitchen pouch (only just moved up to 2 as in 2 meals) a day and a few melty sticky’s here and there but now I’ve been told they need to try BLW and not puree. Am I a bad man? Is there any harm in using pureee? I’m so anxious and have really bad OCD and the thought of him choking on food terrifies me. I know I will have to eventually but he seems happy. Thanks x

Read more on Peanut

The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.

Learn more about our guidelines.
Add a comment
Avatar

I don’t think there’s any harm in purées. I think the main issue is then trying to get them to eat proper food when you do eventually have to move to it, a lot of babies really struggle. They get used to the smooth textures of the pouches.
We did purées for about a week and then just went straight into BLW and he had whatever we had for meals.
I think they say BLW also aids fine motor skills and development too x

Avatar

There is no harm with purées. BLW is not dangerous though. It is just messy and more about the baby experience playing with food. If eating is important for you, then purées are likely better. You will need to introduce thicker baby food eventually. But you can do it little by little.

Avatar

Check out the Solid Starts resources, it may ease your anxiety a bit. It’s hard at first but it gets easier. Babies are actually no more likely to choke on solid food prepared appropriately for their age than they are on purées. And self feeding reduces the choking risk as well. You may feel more comfortable after taking baby CPR as well.

Avatar

I’m doing both some purées and some blw. The good thing about blw weaning is that it teaches them how to work the food around their mouth. With my son he gagged a few times but never choked. Just enough to realize he needed to slow down. They will gag on the food but cause they’ve only had milk. I feel weird about pureeing meat so that we give in big strips they can gum at but I’ve oureed some veggies and fruit. And this way they get used to table food quickly and I don’t have to bring pouches out or stuff.

Avatar

I've been advised by the HV that giving them lumpy food rather than purees is better, as it has no texture.
You could always start with porridge or weetabix, little bit of smashed up banana and raspberries and then work your way up from there 😊

Avatar

BLW can be really fun and we had a blast. Download the solid starts app that guides you on what to give and how to prepare it. I also did a Mini First Aid course for babies and toddlers - cost £25 and think they’re all ok the U.K. (they were ok dragons den years back) They go through choking and food stuff too. Worth it x

Avatar

I am doing both. With Ella's Kitchen, they do get lumpy as the recommended age go up. I started with purees to give her a taste of the food then when LO was happy I introduced the solid version 😅 Then all the whirlwind happens in the kitchen. Just do what works for you. You are not a bad mum. There is not just one way of introducing food and babies are different in their food exploration.

Avatar

No harm at all. But I remember reading with my first that a baby has a natural gag reflex up to 9 or 12months (can't remember exact) so if you BLW it means they learn before that goes away. Personally when I used puree I just made sure to give him something finger food wise that he could play with and eat. But a fed baby is a happy baby, regardless of how. So you do you and whatever works for you is right 🙂. And solid starts on insta is fab x

Avatar

I did traditional weaning with my little boy, slowly changed the consistency of his pureed food to make it more lumpy as he got older, never did any blw at all, the only proper food as so to speak that he had was the odd melty stick/biscuit. My health visitor told me a few times that I should be doing blw as he will struggle but he didn’t at all! He’s now 15 months and eats normal food completely. It’s just been a progression, my mum said that’s exactly how she did it with us when we were younger too, and we were the same, just after 1 eating whole foods. I know all little ones are different, but so are us mums and we shouldn’t be made to feel guilty for how we choose to serve food to our babies. I did attempt giving him more solid food at the start and he did choke, which is what completely put me off, I’ve been told that he won’t have choked just gagged, but he went blue and silent, so was definitely choking. After that I just stuck to what I wanted to do for my baby ❤️

Avatar

Also to add he’s got brilliant had eye coordination, if anything he’s slightly advanced for his age and can use a spoon or fork on his own too 😊

Avatar

You don't have to go to baby led weaning, just adjust the texture so it's not as runny, encouraging chewing. All children appear to choke when beginning the weaning it is their gag reflex more so as they are experiencing something new.

Something I use to do blend a puree and then tiny pieces of pasta/ soft boiled veg I would chop up and add to the smooth puree.

If you buy the next age group pouch you'll see the differences to gradually work up to.

You do not have to do blw if you don't want to.

This page is great and they also have an app.

They discuss choking and techniques to implement and how common it is for children to gag

https://www.instagram.com/solidstarts?igsh=ajM5YnA2NXd3NXY3

Avatar

Do what’s best for your baby. My daughter was on purées. It did her no harm. I used to cook her veg and purée them myself. I think I introduced her to food with bits etc when she was a little older. There’s no rush, just go at your own pace. HV over the years have constantly moved the goal posts. Purées did my daughter no harm and she’s now 2.8 eating rice, chicken, roast dinners pizzas etc

Avatar

I love your post! Although I did a mix of BLW and purées, I think that there is too much pressure for BLW. I really don’t like that.

Avatar

You can also get a chewy stick or myomunchie that is good for tongue and jaw strength to help them learn how to chew. We did purées at first to get him acquainted and then we did BLW; whatever we ate is what we gave him and sometimes made his own foods that we noticed he liked. You can always steam veggies and fruits and keep them whole so they're more soft than solid and they learn to chew/move tongue. There's really not a wrong way to do it but I'd say by the 7-8 month mark, you should switch to solids here or there and then increase. Some kiddos still eat purées after 1yr and that sets them up for feeding difficulties. More practice, the better!

For allergies, the more they're exposed to before 1, the less likely they will develop food allergies. Peanut butter, lentils, chickpeas, eggs, dairy (yogurt or cheese before 1yr), and any kind of fish (salmon, shrimp).

Read more on Peanut

Trending

in our community

Hour night wakes and 5am get up

Can anyone shed some light as to why on earth my child doesn’t want to sleep??? My eyeballs are bleeding!!

Never been a good sleeper, but the problems always changing. He’s nearly 9 months old.

Beginning of the month he dropped to 2 naps. We could put him to bed at 7pm and he’d get up for the day at 6am, with multiple wake ups every 2/3 hours.

Now we put him down at 7pm, he can do a good 4/5 hour stretch, but come 1/2am he’s up every hour then getting up for the day at 5am. This then completely messes up the day because I can’t keep him awake long enough to even get to 7pm, let alone later.

He has 2 naps, roughly about 1hr10 each but it changed based on when he wakes and trying to get him to a reasonable bed time.

What could be the reason for this? 6am is fine, but 5am is not 😩😩

Avatar

1

6

Over supply of milk

I am nearly 5weeks postpartum and I have such a big over supply of BM.
Has anyone donated / sold their supply, if so where do you recommend for this?

Avatar

7

I think its fair

Me and my partner agreed to sleep in 1 day of the weekend.
He doesn't find it fair to look after both kids (my 4 year old isnt his) while i sleep so he looks after the baby while i sleep and my toddlers at his dads and ill look after both the next day.
Straightaway it was pretty unfair as i let him sleep in until he wakes up 10-12
He wakes me up when baby starts fussing because he wants milk (doesnt need it)
I cant pump as i dont supply enough.
So i get woken at 9/9:30 to feed baby then i get him sleep then theres no point sleeping in as my toddlers being dropped off.
I also find it unfair that i get both kids to sleep most night, i get my toddler to sleep everyday hes home (4/5days) and i get my baby to sleep most nights with the exception of maybe twice a month as his dad struggless then about 95% of his thru the day naps.
I have also been unwell for a few months (tumor scare) and am waiting 18 weeks to see a specialist so im obviously petrified for that, so unbelievably tired and alot of aches and pains, specifically these pounding headaches ive been having.
After i had been up til 11:30 getting both kids to sleep lastnight and my partner falling asleep at 10 then him ignoring the baby cries all morning until my toddler woke up im fed up slammed to door and rold him not to expect to sleep in unless he gets the baby to sleep the night b4.
I keep having issues with him not feeling the wet from baby being sick or weeing himself or being able to smell it do about 98% of the time hes given to me i have to clean him up n change him.
Including at night, we agreed my partner would change nappies (1 a night at 5am) while i feed (2,4,5,6:30) but every night when i get him hes pissed through and my partner gets annoyed when i wake him up n moan about it.
Then the morning after hes annoyed at how much washing there is (thats his job) and moans about how often i change myself (baby constantly shits thru and sicks on me) and baby
Honestly im just so tired all the time

Avatar

8

AITA

In the uk there is an outbreak of meningitis, in a specific area mainly. My BD has family from that area and decided to go and meet up with them, I said if he does then he cannot have contact with the kids for 7-10 days after incase he picks anything up. Am I being over dramatic? I reallyyy don’t want my young kids getting anything serious

Avatar

11

Help meeee

!!All advice welcome!! My 5 month old (nearly 6mo) is just not sleeping . Not for naps and not at night . She can’t connect her cycles . We started sleep regression at 3 months but in like how is this nearly been going on for a further 3 months . Like surely not . She has 10 min naps in crib ( which take so much effort ) and maybe 20/30 min naps in my arms/pushchair . She wakes minimum every hour at night with guaranteed false start 20 mins in . I combo feed. I breastfeed her until almost asleep then place her in the next to me crib give her the pacifier and put my hand on her cheek/face for 20 seconds and she drifts off . It’s not really getting her to sleep that’s the issue it’s she just won’t stay asleep . She doesn’t even need to feed much at night usually 1-2 breastfeeds . The rest is comfort wakes needing her pacifier or my hand on her cheek . I’ve looked into sleep associations and independent sleep and I broke the feed to sleep association and rocking and do bedside comforting instead for most wakes which has now lead to my hand being a sleep association on her face . I’m just so exhausted my husband is working mon-fri 9-9 and it’s just me . I haven’t had more than 4 hours in a row since her birth . I can’t get anything done during the day . She is so clingy and cries if I leave room /put her down etc. I love her so much but we both need rest . If anyone has any tips or a routine that could help PLEASE tell me I’ll try anything 🥲❤️❤️

Avatar

3

15

Crawling and walking

So my girl is 9 months now and shes great at sitting up and stays on her tummy for awhile but she seems to have no interest in trying to move or crawl or bum shuffle. Shes a big baby always has been but I'm disabled and I feel like it's my fault she's not hitting milestones I feel like there's something I'm not doing and it's making me a bad mum

Avatar

4

Read more on Peanut