I’ve been slowly weaning my son (22M) off the pacifier. He never really seemed super attached to it before so starting pretty young we’d only give it to him when he was having a hard time or trying to sleep. Then a few months ago we started just giving it to him during naps and bedtime and he did really well. But now we’re trying naps without it and he’s just laying here screaming and I don’t know what to do for him. I’ve been laying next to his crib, singing to him and I keep trying to tuck him back in give him his stuffed animals and rub his back but he’s inconsolable. Do I just let him cry it out? Do I take a break from nap time and try again after lunch? I’m at a loss here 😓
Read more on PeanutThe views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.
Learn more about our guidelines.
At this age, go cold turkey. It’s hard but it’s just a habit.

Also has anyone tried cutting the tip off the pacifier? I’ve seen it on instagram but I’m skeptical about it working or being unsafe?

This is a really difficult age to take it because they just can’t understand why. I limited my daughters just for sleep and then at Christmas (she’d just turned 3) she gave it to Santa for the ‘baby elves’ and hasn’t asked for it since! If it’s not hurting for now then using it for sleep isn’t a bad thing, we just made sure it never left the bedroom so couldn’t be used for anything else.

I've heard the first week going cold turkey isn't fun with lots of no sleep but they're fine after. I still haven't even attempted to wean my 21mo off it because he's just so fussy all the time 😩

Hello

I saw someone take all the pacifiers and said they would bury them and tree/plant would grow. So the made her bury them and then the next day replaced it with a plant and it worked. She’d ask for it and they’d say look it grew a plant. Maybe it could help.

I did cold turkey for both my kids and it was only rough a couple days, I think 13-15m(can't remember their age). You could have them throw it away and tell them bad

yes it works! I did the same with my boy and he started checking every pacifier when I offered him one. And like that he left it.

I’m not a momma to my own yet, but I worked in daycare for years and cutting the tip works, I’ve also used a pin to poke a hole or dipped the pacifier in lemon to get them to reject it. Having a kiddo reject a pacifier themselves takes a few weeks and tears but tends to work well with my experience, the kids I did this with were closer to 13m so it might not be as effective for your kiddo.

I dropped it on the ground right before bed time and said Ups I lost it idk where it went I’m sorry, and put it in my pocket. She looked for it twice with me and even called daddy and forgot about it. :D

Mine stopped with hers after we were down to last one and she put a hole in it by biting it too much, so I guess cutting it off worked.

We only used a pacifier with our son for naps. We took them away when he was 18months old and he settled pretty quickly. We gave him a bottle before bed and sometimes he would take another bottle in the middle of the night. If he asked for a pacifier we would tell him he was too big and we don't use pacifiers anymore.

My son is almost 2.5 I need to wean him off. I am going to do it slowly poke holes in them. He only has them for bedtime.

For my 2 year old, I just said we couldn't find their paci. I would ask them to look for it and when it didn't turn up,I told them we would try the next day to find it. He was never super attached to it, which was obviously helpful. Going cold turkey was the best.