Do coddled babies get independent... Like ever?

Hi
So my son is 21 months old. and people think I have coddled him like a lot. I don't let me do anything dangerous to him or anyone else.. but I am there at his beck and call. He wants to be held, he will be held. He doesn't ever play independently. I am always there at least in the room. I cook and clean only when he is sleeping or his dad is available.
I don't give him screentime unless he is sick. I would like to start but my husband opposes...

My question is, does it get better? Will he ever get independent? Will I be able to leave the room for more than 5 mins?
😢😢

Read more on Peanut

The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.

Learn more about our guidelines.
Add a comment
Avatar

Yes girl. He will feel so safe to be independent bc his momma was so attentive and always there 🩷 you are doing a great job

Avatar

My son didn’t really like independent play until a little past 2. I would try to encourage him to but it just kinda came when he was ready. My daughter on the other hand has always been good and entertaining herself and she is only 15 months. Each kid is different. Before we know it they will be teenagers and on their own.

Avatar

You do really need to be teaching him to play independently at this age really.

Avatar

You aren’t coddling him you are loving him… like your kid is a baby… babies need love and attention… it’s how you build a secure attachment with your kid… don’t rush your baby to being independent cuz it comes sooner than you know! šŸ’

Avatar

I think I should too.. but I can't stand him crying... So suggest me how?

Avatar

@Tanmayee you can stay in the room with him while he's playing. Just try and get him to play on his own while you do something else.

Avatar

I second this, also I had a Velcro baby and she prefers her Dad now. And she can play on her own. Enrolling her in a toddler dance class helped encourage her independence.

Avatar

I understand..
I am just worried I am not doing more harm or setting myself up for super separation anxiety.
Also I want to have some me time by this point...

I see ppl with independent kids, who had let their babies cry when they were little.. and now their life is much easier .. the baby is so independent.
I just want to know will I be able to get that?

Avatar

I think you should do what’s best for you and your child. I am always there for my child except when I’m cooking or taking care of his brother. He does play more independently bc he’s had to. But sometimes he clings to me and I give hugs and cuddle if possible. If not I explain, I’m helping your brother go potty (or whatever I need to finish). When we’re done I’ll cuddle.

If you want him to play more independently you can do play dates so they can see how other kids play. Or model how you play with new toys and he can imitate. But honestly my son is the same age and he really has a lot of fun playing with me and I love it too. Soon they’ll be in school or independent so there’s no rush!

Avatar

Give him time he will get there. My little one was super clingy until 2 years old. Some thing about turning 2 really increases the desire for independence.

Avatar

that is so reaffirming ā¤ļø

Avatar

Independence is not necessarily related to crying. It honestly amazes me how much more independent my second has been and I do not let my kids cry unless I have no other choice. I have always cleaned while my kids are awake and they either play independently or sit with me and 'help'. For my oldest that meant a lot of time helping mom for the first two years of his life. He loves to clean now, and he is very independent while still having a secure attachment to me.

Avatar

First of all you’re not coddling him you’re being a good mom. Yes it does get better, I did the same things with my daughter and she is now two and incredibly independent. Some kids develop imagination later on (mine was one of them) so they don’t want to play alone because they need you to facilitate the imagination portion.

Also do not let your child cry it out it’s cruel and unnecessary. There’s nothing ā€œto doā€ to make your child more independent, they will just do it in their own time.

Avatar

Every child is different and will learn different skills in their own time. This blog post has some helpful tips šŸ«¶šŸ½ https://blog.lovevery.com/child-development/how-to-encourage-independent-play/#:~:text=It%20may%20seem%20counterintuitive%2C%20but,Start%20the%20play%20with%20them.

Avatar

Also @babiesandbrains on IG is a mental health professional who posts about secure attachment often

Avatar

Nope you’re creating a secure attachment, responding to babies and toddlers leads to independence as they then feel safe enough to explore alone, I know what you mean as this age I find tricky as my lo will come get me hold my hand and ask me To sit and play if I’m
Cooking I ask her to join in in her toddler tower or I say mammy is cooking if you want to play with your stickers etc to try encourage a little independent play

Avatar

Girl just take it for someone who has a teenage daughter I'm here to tell you enjoy those cuddles and all the love that you can get when they're little girl because it goes by quick once they get to my daughter's age they don't care about cuddling their mama no more they don't care about none of that it starts getting all about the electronics all about boys all about fashion all about the next Trend enjoy all those cuddles and love while you can get it because you're going to miss it one dayā™”

Read more on Peanut

Trending

in our community

Is this normal?

Is it just my husband that does this? He is able to work from home via his computer and in the mornings and evenings he is on there doing his job. When he is done for the day he tends to stay in the room and either play video games or watch something. He will occasionally come out and play with the girls for a few minutes and that’s it but when I really need him he says he is busy. My daughters are both 1 year old now and I am just wondering how much involvement should he have with them now?
Idk if this is the norm or not…..

Avatar

1

14

Saying NO to buying toys etc

5 year old is getting really envious of others. He is obsessed with items that other kids have at school. I am pestered daily to buy these things in a different style when we already have 3 others. I have seen parents just buying stuff their kid likes which I don't necessarily agree with even when i can afford it. How do you deal with it?

Avatar

10

Daycare?

Thoughts on daycare?? Truly, I am SCARED to be leaving my kid for daycare. I literally do not trust anyone, not even family (they haven’t given me a reason it’s just trust issues on my end, you never know). He’s turning 3 and I’ve been a sahm the whole time but tbh my man doesn’t make enough for us to move out somewhere more calm . We live in a ā€˜not so safe’ area in LA and I’m just not used to living here so I just want us to give my son a better life and in order to speed up the process I would have to work.. I do lashes at home and I’d be open to take new clients so I wouldn’t have to look for work but I’m just scared to lose my license 😭

Avatar

2

6

Tablet for kids

Alright don’t need any negative Nancy’s telling me not to get my 2yo a tablet so if that’s what your gunna do please don’t participate in my poll.

We’re about to move cross country 3+ day trip and my 2yo and 9m hate the car I’m talking scream their heads off till they are out of their seats. We’ve already changed car seats and it didn’t help so I’d like to at least have one entertained and sit next to baby and try and distract her or put her to sleep. Our new car has tvs but since they are rear faced my 2yo can’t see it.

Debating getting her a tablet or dvd player right now on long car rides I end up giving her my phone because I get so overwhelmed sitting in between both of them screaming and crying.

And yes I do bring different toys I bring snacks I play songs try to distract her other ways but for the sake of not losing my mind on this move I think this is best.

-A very overwhelmed and anxious to move mama šŸ˜“

Avatar

18

Thoughts?

your soon to be brother in law (upon inquiry) told you that only a few kids from the family were attending his wedding because they are over the age cut off..

Avatar

8

Separation Anxiety

My baby is nearly 6 months old and has just entered the separation anxiety stage… this evening I was trying to cook dinner whilst my husband was with the baby and he was just crying every time he couldn’t see me, with full blown hysterical sobbing, and as soon as he saw me again he started giggling and smiling. Any tips on how to stop this? And how long might this phase last?
My husband felt pretty disheartened and upset 😢

Avatar

6

Read more on Peanut