Is it damaging to make a child finish their food?

We are having so many problems with our 3 year old at meal times. She doesn’t want to finish her food, comes up with every excuse under the sun (need the loo, my tummy hurts, I’m too tired). Admittedly I’ve done exactly what my parents did … always said “finish your meal please” or “3 more bites” or “no treats if this isn’t eaten”. She’ll refuse a meal and then ask for snacks or treats 10 mins later. Am I actually damaging her relationship with food?

Read more on Peanut

The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.

Learn more about our guidelines.
Add a comment
Avatar

My parents did this and I'll be honest I do not feel that it was to my benefit. I would feel sick when they made me finish something when I was full or when I didn't like it. I would say ok you can stop for now and if she asks for more food you could offer it again or ask why she didn't want it.

Avatar

It’s best to keep feedings and meal times as low pressure as possible.

The more you try to pressure a kid into eating the more pushback you will see.

We give small portions & happily give out seconds!

Big plates full of food are overwhelming to a lot of people’s brains (kid or adult) & I’d rather feel proud dishing out seconds than feel annoyed the food was barely touched

Avatar

I would give her a smaller portion for now, sometimes kids go through a stage of using food as control or they are simply overwhelmed with what’s on their plate.

I usually try and encourage once, sometimes my son just wants me to feed him. If he won’t eat it I let him finish and leave it on the table to see if he comes back to it.
My son isn’t really into snacks but I only offer toast / sandwich as an alternative.

Avatar

I said some rules are needed. In our house if you’re not hungry enough to eat your dinner you’re not hungry enough for a snack. If it’s something I know is hit or miss (mainly meat) I’ll let them have an extra fruit or vegetable of their choice but no bars, crackers, or sweet things. The times I pull out the “3 more bites” is when they’re asking for more pasta but haven’t eaten any vegetables I know they like (today’s problem). If they’re deciding to do other things when they’re supposed to be eating they can go hungry. Most meals we give at least an hour but I f they’re deciding not to eat better luck next time

Avatar

I don't make them finish the food. But if she chooses not to eat, we don't get alternatives. That's her choice and I respect it. But making mealtimes about pressure isn't really productive. It creates a negative association and sometimes it can just be about toddler stubbornness. Food is one of the only things a toddler has control over, so they sometimes refuse to eat as a way of exerting control.

Avatar

My grandma did this and now I have an eating disorder. I struggle with binge eating. So yes this can cause life long issues.

Avatar

I only portion the size of their fists. So if my daughter says she's full, & she's only had half I say "baby, why don't you wait a few and see if you're still not hungry. I never give you too much." Sometimes I'll show her before she eats ill tell her to make fists & she measures it with how much food I put. I learned in early ed their stomach is just that big. So it's not harmful if it's around that size, anything more that's horrible.

Read more on Peanut

Trending

in our community

I’m annoyed at my friend for how she treated my baby in my home.

I have a very active baby who is constantly crawling around and trying to interact with people.
My friend came over today to watch a show and eat. While we were eating, my baby kept crawling over to her because he wanted to interact with her. He wasn’t touching or even able to reach her food, and I was already feeding him my own food, but she repeatedly told him, “No dude, it’s my food.” I eventually told her she didn’t need to keep saying it because he’s still too young to understand.
Later, she got out nail glue to fix her nail. When my baby crawled over, she told him to stop because of the fumes. I told her that if she was worried about the fumes, she could put the glue away or move somewhere else because this is his home and he’s going to crawl around.
Then she put her food bowl on my sketchbook. I asked her to move it because the sketchbook is special to me. She said, “I’ll buy you a new one, they’re cheap.” She ended up spilling rice and oil on it, leaving oil stains, and also spilled rice on my couch.
The sketchbook cost $13, but that’s not the point. I specifically chose that sketchbook because I like the quality and it’s important to me. I was upset that I’d told her it was special and she dismissed it because she thought it was cheap.
I understand she’s childfree and doesn’t particularly like kids, and that’s completely her choice. But this is my home, and I don’t expect my baby to be confined or constantly told off for crawling around and trying to interact with someone. I also don’t bring him to her house because I know her home isn’t baby-friendly and I respect that.
By the end of the visit I was really upset and honestly don’t want to continue the friendship.

Avatar

3

27

Someone gives you a hand-me down. A couple months later, they want it back. You still use it every day. Do you…

In this instance, it’s a potty. A woman I know basically forced it on me. Her kid ended up preferring to go straight in the toilet, but my child struggled with learning to use the potty. We had our own, but she insisted we take hers “you’ll do it in 2 days with this,” and left it at our house.

My child is finally getting the hang of it (took much longer than two days lol) and has weirdly taken to gifted potty and has covered it in stickers so we can’t easily give it back and get a new one, my kid will know the difference and it will be a big deal. I’ve started trying to wean away from the potty onto the toilet.

She hasn’t demanded it back yet but last two times I’ve seen her, she’s hinted she wants it back cause of an issue her kid is having now with the toilet.

I’d happily give it back if we didn’t use it, but I’m worried giving it back will be a whole ordeal for my kid.

Avatar

1

9

Help - how can I get my toddler to play independently

I recently saw a video of 19 month old playing with various open ended toys, each one for 20-40 minutes.

My toddler can just about manage a few minutes before either asking me to play or giving up and moving on to the next thing. I'm a sahm so I'm with her every day but we go to at least 3 stay and play playgroups a week and she will happily play on her own.

I often start an activity but she just wants me to do everything. as soon as I stop she will walk off or if I sit on the sofa she will stop and just sit on my lap. I know I have to play with her but I don't want to spend the entire day playing with her watching and I don't know how else to encourage independant play.

We have blocks, tiles, animals, rainbows, cleaning sets, books, water table, kitchen etc. she will not attempt any type of puzzle which worries me a bit.

The only thing she will do independently for more than a few minutes is drawing. I'm having another baby soon and I'm worried she won't be able to cope without my attention.

Help 🙃

Avatar

10

Would u be irritated? Bf goes to get breakfast because I’m hungry and don’t feel good and only comes back with a chai…. So I end up making my own anyways.

I didn’t say anything and just bit my tongue on the situation

Avatar

3

Crisps

My baby is 16 months and eats crips from the baby isle between 6+m and 12m+ I’m just wondering when and what crips you decided to go onto afterwards as I have the baby ones so much more expensive but also aware of the salt intake and additives in other crisps

Avatar

4

Am I being unreasonable?

We have a 2.5 year old and 5 month old who is breastfed. My husbands insisting we need to do our own things each week to get out of the house and have some time for ourselves. In many ways this would be lovely but he’s barely ever home as he works such long hours so I feel he should be spending that time with the kids. Also, it’s easier said than done saying I should go out for a few hours when our baby is breastfed. I already feel lonely from being on mat leave and not really leaving the house and it would be nice to spend some quality time together. He wants to go and see a 3 hour long film this weekend, meaning he’d be out the house about 5 hours. Am I being unreasonable thinking this is a bit extreme? I do I understand where he is coming from but it just seems a bit unrealistic at the moment .

Avatar

4

Read more on Peanut