The doctor has just told me that there’s no benefit past a year. And when I said that’s a weird thing to say, he told me it’s a fact.
Read more on PeanutThe views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.
Learn more about our guidelines.
that’s absolutely wild and complete misinformation. it is who guidance to continue breast feeding for at least two years. your breast milk still continues to contain essential nutrients and antibodies for your baby.

So wrong!!!

That's awful misinformation and coming from a Dr no less 😒 there are so many benefits to BF past 1 year, WHO recommends BF to 2yrs+, lower risk of cancer, high BP and diabetes for the mother, immune protection to help fight illnesses... the list goes on! And that's not even factoring in the emotional security BF gives your baby and supposedly there's some evidence for cognitive abilities in children who are BF for longer periods too. As well as obviously still providing additional nutritional support alongside food
I would pay no notice at all, he clearly needs to complete some further training. The UK has some of the lowest BF rates worldwide and especially post 6m it's no wonder women don't carry on when they aren't even being supported to do so by healthcare professionals who should know better!!
Having just gone through an awful 2 weeks where my 13m wouldn't eat, wouldn't drink water due to being very unwell, BF saved us from her becoming extremely dehydrated I'm so very glad I'm still BF

I can’t believe your doctor has said that, your breastmilk is also a natural form of antibiotics, always helping and keeping your baby safe. There’s so many benefits inside breast milk that’s not just milk or feeding your baby. I’m so sorry your doctor has said this I’m actually shocked. I’m still breastfeeding. You’re doing amazing!! At the end of the day it’s really down to you and your own circumstances only you can judge not the doctor. Xx

Who are these doctors?!? There are soooo many benefits! As Hannah mentioned above the WHO recommends it! And from a nuture prospective, soooo beneficial for both you and your baby. Keep on BF!

My baby would say otherwise and he's all that matters. As long as they're not saying it's been proven it's bad for them I'll do it until my baby weans himself off 😊

Still breastfeeding here! Also pregnant with my second and have no intention of stopping breastfeeding my little one when our new baby is born! Even if he is just feeding for comfort that is still a benefit in my eyes! As mentioned above by others there are so many benefits to continuing to breastfeed! Some cultures breastfeed until up to age 7, so that doctor’s comments are wild! You just have to do what is right for you and your little one! I am so disappointed in the advice and information people receive from medical professionals!

Still BF, amongst house moves, moving in temp with parents, nursery changes and a constant change of routine it’s been a source of comfort and consistency. So there can be other benefits than just nutrition

Completely untrue!!

Aside from all the benefits listed above, you also get increased protection from Ovarian and Breast cancers the longer you breastfeed. 4.3% decrease in risk for every 12 months of breastfeeding. 🙌🏻

Please report this to your surgery, or higher if this doctor is a practice partner.

I would complain about this

So sorry this happened to you 😞 I was amazed to see how few children are still breastfed at age 1, compared to other countries, and attitudes like this really don't help. Breast milk is amazing and while it shouldn't form a child's main source of nutrition after the age of 1, it still definitely has a place. I am currently expressing milk for my 12 month old (she bites every feed so it was pump or give up, and I wanted her to continue having breastmilk), she eats for England but still loves a few bottles throughout the day, and I plan for her to have access to breastmilk for at least another year, as per WHO guidance.
Ignore your Dr-if breastfeeding is still working for you and your family, then carry on. You're doing an amazing job

What a silly thing for a doctor to say. So many benefits. Please please formally raise it so other women are protected from this misinformation.

Would be a bloke too! Clueless

It’s definitely not a fact and he really should know this as a GP. Agree with others please complain! Guidance is 2 years by WHO. The UK is not good at this and then we wonder why when Drs are telling people their opinions are facts!

You should absolutely complain about this. It’s completely factually incorrect not to mention in contradiction to the WHO guidance !! Breastfed my oldest to 2.5 and it was helpful in illness, night time wakes etc. only stopped as had to for IVF meds.
will bF this one as long as poss.

https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/infant-and-young-child-feeding
This is about feeding between 12-24 m, and I’d report this doctor!

The nurse at my GP practice said this to me a couple of weeks ago, and she used to be a midwife!! Unfortunately I think breastfeeding is really undervalued in this country. It’s amazing to still be able to give our little ones all the benefits that breast milk offers

Well he’d have a fit with me then as I’m still feeding my 3.5 year old before bed 😅 What a crazy thing for an actual doctor to say who should be encouraging it.
My 2 year old keeps waking up at 5am and is cranky and tired enough that she wants to go back to sleep but needs lots of cuddles. But because by this point sleep pressure is low she’s takes over an hour to resettle and fall back to sleep. By this point my alarm is going off 6:15am for work 😖😩
She used to wake up nicely around 7am and we’d all be a lot calmer and have breakfast together but now I’m either letting her sleep in a bit so she’s not over tired and there’s always a big rush to get out the door.
Any tips?
She goes to bed at 8-8:30pm naps around 1pm for 1h-1h:30m
3
I’m looking for recommendations on a baby sling instead of a carrier or wrap, I’ve got both which my baby loves especially when it comes to nap time but it’s a mission getting on and off and she is getting heavier. I just want something quick and easy and didn’t know these even existed! She will be 2 months so not much neck control yet but is 12lbs 14oz, so conscious it needs to be decent for proper support.
Any mums have a sling that they’ve used from this age by any chance that they’ve loved?

11
When should I get worried that my son is showing little interest in crawling? He’s 8 months old? He’s great and sitting and has just started spinning when he sits but will refuse to go on his tummy.

1
14
How do I explain to my partner that I don’t appreciate the fact he just expects me to do all of the night time feeds and changes, even when my baby is on my side of the bed when my partner doesn’t work? I would understand if he was working etc, but he doesn’t work so I don’t get why it’s not fully 50/50? Like even when we eat he cooks his own food first when our son is due a bottle so I feed and sit him up for the recommended half an hour before feeding myself, it’s just feels very selfish on his part. I don’t know if it’s me being dramatic or hormonal but it’s starting to get to me, for detail our son is 8 weeks
1
3
Guys I’m struggling! I know all babies develop at different rates but should I be concerned? My boy is 15 months and is some ways he’s smashing it and in other ways he seems very behind! He can count to 10, started doing his abcs and can say alot of words, but he can’t say mama and Dosent use dada meaningfully, he can’t clap or wave but can walk, point and has started feeding himself, he can tell me
What noises alot of animals make and what they are but he 9 times out of 10 dosent answer to his name, but he will bring me books and toys and sit and read and play with me and struggles ALOT with food, it’s a struggle to get food in him most days but other days! At what point should I be worried!

3
Hello mamas!! At what age did your little ones start talking? My son is 1.5 and he seems close but hasn’t said anything yet

5