do you believe “not every cry needs attention” ??

For example, your baby is crying even though you’ve done everything. They’re fed, they’re burped, they’re changed, they’ve slept. do you believe letting them cry it out sometimes is okay when you aren’t sure what they’re crying over or what else you can do to help them??

I see multiple different opinions on this

Read more on Peanut

The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.

Learn more about our guidelines.
Add a comment
Avatar

Sometimes.
I think babies are usually always crying for a reason though. They aren’t machines that just need feeding, burping and sleep. They need connection, communication, joy etc.

I don’t think there’s anything wrong with letting them cry sometimes though!

Avatar

I don’t really believe in “cry it out” for babies ever, I do think it’s fine to leave a baby crying if everything is fine & your just tryna get something done real quick, but I also think all cries deserve acknowledgment, it’s a babies only way to communicate, nothing has to be physically wrong for there to be a want or need for comfort.

Avatar

I just assume there's something else going on that I can't physically do anything for, maybe trapped wind I couldn't get out, maybe something else hurts, maybe she just needs comfort, and that's enough for me to pick her up. I'd much rather she's crying on me than crying alone in her bassinet.
That being said, there's absolutely times where you need to put your crying baby down and walk away to breathe.

Avatar

Sometimes sure. I think if all needs are met, and you’re in the middle of something, like going to the bathroom, showering, etc., I don’t think you need to jump right that second and cut your poop short to attend to them lol.

Avatar

Nope it’s their only method of communication so I believe they don’t ever cry for nothing. We might think it’s nothing but it never is to them.

Avatar

No. All crying has a reason even if I can't figure out the why. A baby thats fed can still be hungry, changed can need to be changed again, slept but needs more sleep, needs some love and attention. Can I always respond immediately? No. If I cannot physical touch the baby at that moment I call out to the baby and acknowledge the cry.

Avatar

Sometimes yes, it depends, if all needs are met and there's nothing obvious upsetting them in the environment around them (bright lights, loud noises, etc), and they're not after physical contact, then yeah.

Our daughter would stir in the night when she was younger and cry a little but it would only last 10secs at most and she wouldn't fully wake up, she'd find her thumb and go back to sleep. So I stopped rushing to her in the night if I heard her, unless she'd been crying for like 30secs+, then I'd know that she needed something.

Sometimes during the day now as a toddler, she has big feelings and feels the need to cry, so I let her for a few minutes whilst being close by, then when she's ready she'll come to me for a hug and to self-regulate. Then if she needs something she'll ask me for it, like help putting on her shoes or opening her juice bottle, etc (it's usually when she's gets frustrated with not being able to do things on her own 😅).

9 times out of 10 she won't cry without a good reason xx

Avatar

Also a midwife once said to me that "a safe, crying baby is better than a dead baby", if you do need to just walk away for a few minutes for a breather on a really hard day. Haven't ever really needed to do this, but it's a piece of advice that has stuck with me over the years xx

Avatar

Sometimes they just want a cuddle/to be near you etc so no I don’t think it’s ever ok to let them ‘cry it out’, I mean if you hear a few moans that stop after a couple of seconds etc then that’s different. However if you are holding them and they don’t stop crying then that’s ok as you’re still there.
The caveat would be here is if you are really struggling mentally and you need to leave them crying for their safety for a minute somewhere safe then that’s ok.

Read more on Peanut

Trending

in our community

Diaper change

If baby poops just as she is falling asleep. Do I change her and disrupt her sleep or let her sleep but with poop😩? Help

Avatar

12

Car Seat

Hiya girlies,
My 6mo is pretty tall and she’s already outgrown her car seat. Could anyone recommend any good value car seats, preferably online as it’d be easier to get?
Amazon would be a good shout, but even like Argos or something works too.

Thanks in advance xxx

Avatar

1

10

I let my baby cry it out

My baby is 3 months old. We’re not officially starting sleep training but today has been brutal. He had been up for 4 hrs and was so fussy because he was exhausted, but he would not go to sleep. I tried nursing him to sleep, rocking him to sleep, walking around the house with the baby carrier, walking around without the baby carrier, laying him down on the bed next to me, having sensory time in his playgym, reading to him, singing to him, NOTHING was working. So I laid him down in his cot awake and fussy and sat downstairs watching on the monitor. He cried for about 10 minutes, then fell asleep.

I feel like a terrible mom that I couldn’t soothe him to sleep, he was just so overtired nothing was working. He’s fast asleep now but I don’t know if what I did was right. I told myself 10 minutes and if he’s still crying I’ll go try to soothe him again. But as I was literally getting up to get him, he went from crying to silence. I went in to make sure he was ok anyways because the immediate change from crying to not kind of scared me, but he was totally fine. Fast asleep.

Is it ok to let him cry himself to sleep occasionally at this age?

Avatar

25

4 month old

Sleep regression.. what the hell is this madness 😂😂 I feel like I’m going mad he was only 4 months old on Friday and safe to say it’s started! How do I stay sane

Avatar

2

8

Sleeping

My daughter has just turned four and she still wakes up multiple times a night.

We have trialled later bed time/ earlier, bath before bed, making sure she has something like porridge to eat before bed. Letting her have tv/ no tv. We have tried night light no night light. We have altered her room lay out


She is put in bed about 7 she stays up until 11ish then she wake up around 2am and stay up until 7ish then wake up around 8 for the day she has no day naps and doesn’t seem tired

Any suggest please 🙂

Avatar

7

Losing People due to life changes

So I got married last November. Pretty much conceived on my honeymoon. And we are now expecting our babygirl at the end of August. With all the life changes that have happened to me in the past year. I have notice I have lost some friends who can't grasp that my life has changed and will continue to change. Because my child ain't going no where. And will always be my priority. My priorities are different and it's like these Gen z friends of mine just don't get it. It's been low-key annoying and stressing me out because I'm like umm I can't change being pregnant and I can't change that I'm a wife, stepmom, and gma all at the same time now. My life is different. And I'm being penalized 😔 anyone else going or gone through this type of bullshit. It's why I hang with my generation and older normally. Cause zillennial (young ass millennials) and gen z just cut different (in a very immature way) .

Avatar

3

8

Read more on Peanut