Breasfeeding vs pumping

Hi there!
Looking for opinions and experiences.
I had an emergency C, and my milk came in late, so we had to start with formula. Worked on it and my milk came, but baby is now used to bottle. Managed to make him latch a few times, but ut was painful and after a while he was getting a bit frustrated, i guess because of the flow. So i stuck with pumping.

Now here's my dilema :
Yes, i have to pump regularly every 2-3 hours. So not getting too much sleep. My husband insists it would have been loads easier if i would have kept trying to breastfeed, so i wouldn't get out of bed, having to get the milk ready all the time, and even he could get more sleep. So i think this is all one sided, as he would get more sleep, and i would get even less, as i thought breastfeeding would mean even less sleep because babies do lots of cluster feeding? As in i could end up feeding every 10 20 min compared to every 2-3h?


There's pros and cons for both exclusively breastfeeding and exclusively pumping (especially for the future on this as i will end up just giving the bottle to the baby and feed himself while i have a bit of time for myself - under supervision ofc)

Any takes on this? Anyone who switched from one to another? What do you think was easier?

Read more on Peanut

The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.

Learn more about our guidelines.
Add a comment
Avatar

I just exclusively pumped. I had a schedule of every 4 hours at about 3 months pp, before that there wasn't a schedule it was when I felt I needed to (plus I actually cant remember how often I did in those early days)
Pumping is hard and so is nursing.
Either way feeding mainly falls on the mum. And sometimes breastfeeding is hard and doesn't work out, that was my case.
My partner was encouraging of my pumping, even when I had to wake him to hold baby in the night.
If you want to try feeding at breast, give it a go. But pumping is also an option, if you're able to do it too.
Its definitely up to you, and how you feel

Avatar

I didn't have to give bottle to my baby to start with but after my emergency section latching was incredibly painful for at least 2 weeks, the silver cups were a bit helpful to me. My take on this is, maybe it would be worth trying the breast? My baby now sleeps a 4/5 hours stretch and my body just adjusts and fingers crossed someday she sleeps longer, the breastaurant will hopefully get the memo.

Also, cluster feeding doesnt last forever. And if she does cluster feed I'd like to think it's for a good reason!

I currently do a pump after my morning feed and give a bottle of expressed milk a day so she gets used to it.

Worth saying that going to a lactation consultant will be best. All the very best!

Avatar

Your husband should be supporting your decision. It isn't easy to breastfeed for everyone, especially in your situation where you have had to bottle feed first. I breast fed and I've never felt so lonely in my life, not because my husband didnt support me, but being awake in those early hours of cluster feeding is so isolating. But my husband would wake up with me, help with nappy changes, hold baby whilst I went to the bathroom and help me get comfy to feed before going back to bed. It was also his idea to try a bottle so he could help me out overnight and we switched at about 5 months to formula. I'd personally keep pumping as you are, but you have to make the decision for you and baby, not for your husbands sleep needs. Once my son was older we also started alternating nights that we would get up with him so one of us could have an almost uninterrupted sleep, that helped massively!

Avatar

My baby was super premature, sleepy feeder, tongue tied, emergency c section, everything worked against breastfeeding g so I’m pumping. My partner would feed him bottles in the night whilst I pumped. My the time he was about 8 weeks corrected he was very big, maybe I fed him too much milk or he never had to work hard for it but he sleeps 8 hours every night now and that’s great. 6 months on I’m starting to I tridu e formula as I do t wa t to be tied to a pump anymore.

Read more on Peanut

Trending

in our community

Cradle cap

What are mamas using for cradle cap?

Avatar

1

34

Car seat

I know the car seat I want, but I don’t have the money to afford it at this moment. Anybody know how I can get a car seat that is safe and the one I want for a good offer?

Avatar

20

Chunky thigh baby mamas (&papa's)

My 4 week old LO has a juicy pair of thighs, any nappies or clothes around thighs are leaving a red imprint

Nappy size is not ready to size up yet as would be way too baggy, only just sized up to size 2 (using pampers as got loads on offer)

And tips or advice?have seen someone mentioned putting nappy cream / petroleum jelly on the thighs as barrier from rubbing

Avatar

7

🤢🤢

I'm not washing my clothes with my husbands anymore. He sweats so much you can wash his shirts and they still smell like his under arms.. do you wash your clothes with your husband's ?

Avatar

18

Sleeping past 5 am

Please help my little one is nearly 8 months old and it doesn’t matter what time she goes to bed she always wakes between 5 and 6 am and won’t go back to sleep till between 9 and 10

Edit: she goes to bed between 8 and 10 we do a dinner at 5 and a bottle at half 7. Naps wise I’m lucky if she will nap for more than half hour at a time and if she does 3 naps I’m lucky most of the time it’s just 2 naps a day

Avatar

8

4 month sleep regression

How are we actually surviving and what do we even do?!! I’m at my wits end of a week of frequent wake ups, false starts, being dead asleep and then being put down and waking and starting the cycle all over again!! Since two weeks old she’s slept with only one wake up at 5am so I am DONE IN!! Do we just ride this out of what the hell do we actually do to solve this? It’s HELL

Avatar

16

Read more on Peanut