Coming off formula

Has anyone ever been advised by the dietician to take their baby off formula before 1? My son is almost 9 months and we spoke with a dietician a few days ago who advised me to swap him off his alfamino and put him onto oat milk, but a few people have said he should be staying on formula until one. I’m just unsure if to go ahead with it or to get a second opinion x

Read more on Peanut

The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.

Learn more about our guidelines.
Add a comment
Avatar

I was told to keep my daughter on formula until she was 12 months corrected! She was born 6 weeks early, so will be nearly 14 months by the time I transition her x

Avatar

I’m just so unsure on what to do. She told me to start milk free weaning at first.. I said you are aware he’s nearly 9 months he’s been having food for a few months now 🙄. I did try him with a little oat milk yesterday and he spat it out and wouldn’t have it so I’m just using it in his food at the moment instead of his alfamino but I’m just not sure on completely taking him off formula so soon xx

Avatar

My little girl stayed on Aptamil Pepti formula til 1 and have just weaned her completely onto the Alpro Growing Up milk which is soya☺️

Avatar

How much formula is he drinking daily right now? I don’t think you should take him off the formula personally. Has he been tested for CMPA recently? My son outgrew his when he was 10 months old and we were able to put him back on Kendamil! Before the Kendamil we used HippHA.
Just curious why they think you should take him off the formula 🤔

Avatar

he has around 3-4 7oz bottles a day but sometimes doesn’t finish the whole bottle and also has water during the day. He hasn’t recently been tested, he has his allergy testing next month finally but he was referred for allergy testing and the dietician at 4 weeks and he’s almost 9 months now. They mentioned the milk challenge but advised me not to do it as his milk allergy was so severe it caused severe eczema too and his skin was raw at one point so they’ve said to just avoid it until the testing but want him off formula and just having oat milk only. I’ve never heard of them advising this before so I’m just a little concerned about doing it x

Avatar

Did they ever mention about coming off the formula early? I’m just confused as to why they’ve advised it with him not even being 9 months yet. I did try him with some oat milk yesterday but he refused it x

Avatar

nothing was ever mentioned, although I never got a dietician appointment until she turned 1 - 9 months after she was diagnosed🙃
If you want to stick with his formula then I would. They get all their vitamins from it and most people don’t wean to cows milk until 1 anyway. You could start using oat milk in porridge or other foods to help get him used to the alternative. I’d recommend the alpro growing up milk personally (can be found with long life shelf milk)

Avatar

the wait lists are so long arent they it’s a shame! I did use an alpro one yesterday to try but he just spat it out and refused it but he does seem to have it with his porridge just fine. She also said she wanted me to wean him completely off bottles and just onto sippy cups which I also thought was weird? He still feeds to sleep sometimes so god knows how that’s meant to work 😂 x

Avatar

I would definitely seek a second opinion here. Baby has already been through so much with a milk allergy and I was under the impression that milk had to be their primary source of food until 12 months. If baby was like 11 months that better but 9 months?? Seems very early to me.

Avatar

Exactly what I thought, 9 months seems far too soon to me too! I’ll definitely be calling his paediatrician today for a second opinion! X

Avatar

such a shame, could’ve had way more help earlier than I have. Have you tried adding it in the bottle with his formula? Just 1oz see if he takes it? It’s a bit of an adjustment but I just lowered the amount of formula and increased the amount of alrpo. Why wean off bottles yet?! My daughter is capable of holding her bottle but she prefers me to feed her before bed and have a cuddle! Do what feels best for you, just take what they say as guidance imo x

Avatar

I know, the support has been non existent! No but I will be trying that next I think, I even tried it a little warm but he’s such a milk monster for his alfamino (not sure how it stinks 😂) and no idea! He does have his water from a MAM trainer cup with a spout but he’s the same, he feeds to sleep with a cuddle so I don’t feel ready to take that away from him yet! Xx

Avatar

It’s all new protocols and it’s to save money on the prescriptions!!
My older 3 all had cmpa and were given their prescription milk till they stopped taking it. One was 12 months, one 15 months and one 17 months.
But with our youngest we were told to find a milk he will have, as the prescription will be stopping at 12 months no matter what. I just bulk ordered my prescriptions up till his birthday so I’ve got a good stock as he refused all other milks x

Read more on Peanut

Trending

in our community

Can someone pls help i keep making this post and nobody is responding

My boyfriend booked a trip for us to go to mexico for a week as my push present. I have severe anxiety leaving my 7 month old with my mom. I know she will be in good hands but she’s exclusively breast fed for the most part but accepts bottles just fine. i have all my pumping parts packed and will pump when baby normally eats but i don’t want baby to forget me or have latch issues when i return!! any mommas ever experience this?

Avatar

10

Postpartum

I’m only 3 days postpartum (FTM) and already have extremely bad anxiety. I’m crying every night, as I think of another night of no sleep. My baby will not settle in his cot, he cries every moment we put him down unless in his chair rocker. So me and my partner are having to alternate after 3/4 hours of being awake with him downstairs. I’m trying everything to get him to settle. It’s a load of overwhelming stress. I’m 23, I was desperate for a baby and now I have one and feel completely useless. I miss it just being me and my partner.

Avatar

4

24

When does it get better?

I was crying on the phone with the perinatal mental health team today and the lovely lady, bless her, kept assuring me that it gets better. I kept telling her I hope so because people have been saying that since having my LO and it just feels like it keeps getting worse. She assured me it gets better....

Avatar

1

8

Night time routine

Heya, my 3 week old daughter is currently exclusively breastfed and I’m not pumping. Can anyone recommend the best way to share the load with my partner? At the moment I’m doing all the feeds/burbs/settling and my partner is sleeping through which obviously isn’t sustainable, I’m trying to work out the best way to get him involved. Any advice very much appreciated!

Avatar

6

Rapid cool/ hot shot method

Sorry if this sound stupid but how are we doing the hot shot method?
Are we boiling the kettle and letting it cool a little before adding to hot flask? Then with the cool water do you boil the kettle and leave it to cool right down before putting into another flask?
My baby brain is fried trying to work out the easiest way!

Avatar

7

Rant/WWYD

My sister (youngest, 24) has two kids, 4 & 1, and i (oldest, 30) just have my one who’s 6mo old right now, so i ask her for advice or call her to vent about things sometimes. Well im tired of her turning around and telling my other family members that I’m “losing my sh*t.” Literally have not lost my sh*t nor have i ever freaked out to her about my baby, i just call her to talk and tell her what stage my baby is in or talk through how im feeling, but she chooses to tell people that im like a complete nutcase or something which worries me that my family is going to start being judgmental about me as a mother or looking at me funny like I’m some fragile ticking time bomb.

What would you do in this situation? I’m already pretty much decided that I’ll stop telling her anything about my struggles, but I’m almost at the point where i feel like it should be confronted because she, of all people, should understand what I’m going through.

Avatar

10

Read more on Peanut