Husband has been really trying to use the “good girl” pressure to make our 3 year old behave, she is a very stubborn little girl and has massive outbursts, but I believe we can manage it without using this pressure.
He’s started getting her to repeat “nice girls get nice things and bad girls get nothing” and it’s starting to make me feel uncomfortable, but I can’t quite put my finger on why.
Anyone have any tips on how to navigate this?
The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.
Learn more about our guidelines.
I don’t have a girl yet, but we still don’t use language like that.
We say to our son “cooperation & calm lungs help us get the things we want” if/when I have a daughter the same language will continue with her as well.

Sounds like something she might accept from a future abusive, manipulative boyfriend.
Weird language ! She's not being a bad girl.. She's 3 years old...

Anything about gender is unhelpful, good or bad. Sometimes my son will say stuff like 'is this for big boys' and I'll say 'big kids'. You're essentially avoiding anything that relates something to gender unnecessarily. Boys have a willy/penis, can't get round that, but behaviour etc doesn't need any correlation, even if you may notice some. In this instance id be using natural consequences with behaviour and we also 1,2,3 magic. As others have said, she's being a toddler, not a bad girl.

We use words like naughty and behavior. You still have time to curve the way she says and accepts words. You should be more consistent with her dad, Id correct him in front of her just as a more assertive way to express yourself

Eveyone made a good and bad choices. Making a bad choice does not make you bad. There are no bad girls or good girls. Label the behavior not the kid