Am I being unreasonable?

My wife and I are have a 3 year old daughter. My mother in law is clearing out her conservatory and wants to give some of the baby toys amd equipment to her son and his girlfriend who's baby is due in February. Of course that's up to her when it's stuff she had brought.
But I don't think it's fair we should be expected to give her the stuff we brought for her daughter that weve kept at their house because we are planning on having more children in the near future.
She says why wouldn't we buy our future child their own toys.
We're not made of money, we live within our means but my wife has disabilities and I'm her carer so we only claim benefits (UK based).
Am I being unreasonable by not letting my brother in law and his girlfriend have our stuff?

Read more on Peanut

The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.

Learn more about our guidelines.

Add a comment

I guess my only thought is if you've left them there, your daughter no longer plays with them, and you haven't collected them to save already, I understand why your MIL is suggesting gifting them on/is a little confused about why you want them. However if you've expressed that you want them then it's weird for her to be pushy about giving it all away! That's your stuff at the end of the day it's not hers to give and it's not her business to tell you what to do with it.

I wouldn’t say you’re being unreasonable or not. But you did say in the future you’ll have more, maybe you and the family can come to an agreement that the toys stay in the family and you and your wife’s next future child will get them when the time comes? Maybe compromise the least favorite toys and then set a boundary for the favorite/ memorable toys?

I understand the storing the baby items at the in laws, we do it too! Sometimes you don’t have extra room and the in laws do😅

I see both sides.
Without a second thought, i would happily let my sister take what she needed and hand it back over when they're done with it 😊 but that would be my call, I'd be annoyed if my mom just gave her my stuff.

If you want your stuff then you need to go get it and store it yourself. Your kids not playing with them and if its stuff shes even considering for a new baby then its stuff your kid hasnt used in QUITE some time. In THIS scenario since theres no current pregnancy for you guys and you dont actually know when or if there will be another, have a conversation with them. Theres no reason it cant come back to you if/when you guys need it again. Right now youre only at a hypothetical stage, how long is she supposed to keep your stuff for a child that may not happen and may be a different gender?

I think the same explanation can go to gifting the second hand toys to her son and gf bc y not she buy them their own toys . If u really want to keep the toys go pick them up and bring them home for a while

Shit wrong button I meant not being unreasonable

in our community

Told my husband I’m leaving him

He refuses to stop having an inappropriate relationship with his “best friend” who is a woman that has repeatedly told both of us she does not like me, she does not want to be my friend, and she is waiting for me to leave so she can be with my husband. She makes weird comments in front of him about how good she is in bed, and she enables his bad behaviors that damage our family.

I have asked him to stop talking to her but he says nothing is going on. I said this is about respect. He said he’s known her longer than me, and I’m just being petty and jealous over nothing.

I said he always picks her side over mine, always goes to her instead of me, and frankly I’m over it. I’m the wife and this is not a competition. If he cannot respect our marriage and continues to have an emotional affair with this woman I will leave.

He told me to go. 😂😂 I am so angry rn.

Am I overthinking?

I have caught a sickness bug off my 2 year old and really struggling at the moment as I also have a 6 month old baby and my partner is working long shifts. I have been offered a hand from my in laws to take my toddler for a few hours whilst I try and get some rest but feel very 50/50 as in my head I do not want anyone assuming I don’t look after my kids when I have them 100% of the time. Probably just sound silly even thinking this, what’s your opinion?

Childcare dilemma

My little one will need 3 days of childcare when I return to work next year and we have already reserved her a nursery spot for these days. My mother in law has previously commented about wanting to have my daughter for 1 day per week but for various reasons I would prefer for my daughter to attend nursery for all 3 as currently planned, which is what I feel most comfortable with right now. My dilemma is the upset/ tension this would potentially cause and that my partner doesn’t seem to think it will be an issue and has not had this conversation with her. I can sense she is waiting for this but he feels otherwise.
I also can’t help but wonder if my reasonings are unreasonable or not for this decision.. or if they’re totally ok as I’m her Mum and I have to be comfortable with it. My partner is ambivalent on the decision and doesn’t mind either way. My reasons are…
1. I would like my daughter to have consistency in her week and not to be between my care, a relatives and then nursery (I’m aware many do this without issue)
2. I would like the flexibility of being able to drop off and pick up my daughter when I’m able to and early if i desire; it is also 5 minutes down the road rather than 25 minutes
3. My mother in law has been overly involved with my niece and tries to take over parenting (in my opinion) which I do not want to happen with us
4. I would not feel comfortable to challenge my mother in law if needed around the care she provided like I could with nursery
5. I don’t feel my mother in law is respectful of our parenting decisions and suspect she would go against these and seek to undermine them if looking after my daughter
6. I would rather my mother in law’s time with my daughter to be on a more informal basis; it will still be promoted, just around our lifestyle and what works for us

Has anybody made this decision for similar reasons?