Is divorce over smacking extreme?

We have a 4 year old and have always done gentle parenting but as she has got older and become more boisterous she's started hitting. I do the standard gentle parenting stuff but my husband has decided he's had enough of it and started hitting back. I'll be clear he does not beat her and never smacks hard enough to leave a mark. It also only ever 1 smack. But to me that's not the point and I can't stand it. He has decided gentle parenting doesn't work it and I can't get him back on the same page as me. I'm considering leaving him and I don't want the kids raised in an environment where hitting is ok or send the message that it's ok for men who love her to hit her. I've said hitting as discipline is a deal breaker to me. He thinks I'm over reacting and doesn't plan to change. Am I over reacting? Is it weird to break up a family over it? Our relationship is fine other wise. It is literally just him as a dad (he is a bit crap in other ways as a dad too e.g. would rather go out with his mates to pub than spend day as a family). What do I do?

Read more on Peanut

The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.

Learn more about our guidelines.
Add a comment
Avatar

I don't think you're overreacting particularly, as you're absolutely right that hitting back is not the way to teach that hitting is wrong, it's just illogical. He's not going to be hitting when he's calm and rational, he's going to be hitting when he is angry so he's showing her that the correct way to react when she's feeling angry is to hit.
I'd also be worried that he doesn't seem to be listening to you, and is dismissing something that is so important to you and a fundamental value you hold.
I'd be trying to explain to him again why this is so important to you. You could also find something for him to watch and say "I know you're unsure about this, I wanted to share this to explain more my point of view and see what you think".
I'd also be clearly saying to him "I will stop you if you hit our child, my job is to keep her safe". Maybe that would make him think about what he's doing, would he actually be willing to hit you to then hit her.

Avatar

He's wrong. You guys agreed not to use physical discipline, and he needs to stick to that.

How long has your daughter been hitting people? Let me be clear, I don't think he should be hitting her regardless. But if the hitting has been going on for a while, I think both of you need to find a new way to discipline her. You can still do gentle parenting, but differently than whatever you've been doing because it isn't work.

Avatar

By hitting her back, he is showing your daughter that it is ok to hit - and so is reinforcing your daughter’s behaviour. It is the same as telling your daughter off for swearing, by swearing at her - which is extremely confusing for a child. If I were you I would gather together some resources/research that teach about why hitting is not the best method of discipline, and ask him to read the materials and evidence. Maybe then he will allow his opinion to be challenged by the findings of scientists and developmental psychologists. E.g https://www.developmentalscience.com/blog/2022/2/10/hitting-children-leads-to-trauma-not-better-behavior

Avatar

If he is not willing to be challenged at all on this, it is so understandable for you to think about divorce out of your desperation - you’re a good mother for wanting to protect your children and raise them in a healthy environment. I would always suggest first going to couples therapy - his parenting style is likely just learnt from his own upbringing and so never been questioned. Therapy might help him to question why he believes what he believes and to see that it likely had an adverse effect on him when he was a child and will also do the same to his children

Avatar

Hitting her where? Same as she has hit someone and not a spanking?

Avatar

I don’t think you’re overreacting. I told my husband that I would leave him if he was ever physical with our children. The only issue is, if you do leave him, he will probably continue to do the things that you don’t like, just without your knowledge. I would really try and speak to him and explain how much this means to you.

Read more on Peanut

Trending

in our community

I've finally done it

I have finally done it. I have finally become the trope, the stereotype.

I have become bitter, resentful, and very overwhelmed and overloaded. I am very unhappy and hit burnout. And I snapped at my husband last night. I work full-time, and work has been very busy so im working late a lot. Im also in grad school. I also have a toddler that has become VERY clingy with me. My husband works shorter days but commutes, so he usually gets home after me by an hour or more. When he gets home, he usually heads to the restroom for at least 30 mins when he gets home. And now my toddler doesnt want anything to do with him. So im doing all the toddler duties until bed. I dont get 5 mins to myself. Not for almost 2 years. I finally hit my wall. I have also, somehow, become my MILs medical ride service and she somehow has an appt every week, it seems?! Shes not sick!! My husband was complaining that he needs to change routine to fit in a workout sometimes, and I lost it. I have been BEGGING for 5 mins to myself for months. I have been telling him how im not good, im going to burn out for months. And between his attitude and him complaining (which really got me b/c he blames me for not being able to work out?! Saying I need help when he gets home so he just cant workout now) I just lost it completely. I told him how unfair my life has become and I have the entire mental and emotional load and it is just not fair. He got mad at me and said "hes trying" when hes literally not trying at all. What do I do?? No one is taking the load from me! And im done and dont know what to do now.
I do not like this version of me.

Avatar

4

20

AITA?

This isn't a major issue, just wondering if I'm being a bit of an asshole.

• I do shift work, 5 out of 7 days, full-time.
• My partner works from home (mostly, sometimes he goes into the office) M-F, full-time.

Anyway, whenever I have a day off during the week he gets in his feelings when I make myself food (breakfast and lunch) but not him. His reason is he's working, I'm not - Which is fair but I've asked him how many times on a weekend has he gotten up, on his day off and made me breakfast and a lunch to take with me to work? You guessed it, 0.

So basically, just because I'm at home I don't think the responsibility to feed him should automatically fall on me when he manages to feed himself just fine while I'm at work.

Avatar

25

Big vent!

Hi mums.
I'm a first time mum in my 40s to twin boys.They are almost 5 months old and the biggest miracle in my life!
I am struggling!!!
I'm pretty sure I have ppa as my pregnancy was a very high risk and all I remember was crying from anxiety of all the ifs!Thankfully even born at 35 weeks and skinny,didn't need iu time.
My husband is not helping much because he's always too busy with work.He will "look" after them usually between 8pm-12am so I can have a chance to sleep.
He expects me to just sleep when I touch the pillow,even though I hear tje babies crying and him don't really bother because most of the times he'll be on his laptop working.
When I tell him I can't relax to fall asleep because I feel you r neglecting the babies,he says I'm the problem becauae I'm always there with them and don't give them alone time!!
I am angry!!I am furious!!
I can't keep.up.with housework becauae someone alwaya neess me and most of the times they nap I either cook and clean tje kitchen,do laundry or try and take a quick nap.
He doesn't help.around the house,becauae..guess what?always super busy.
I asked him nicely we could clean the house together every Saturday morning so it's easier and quicker for both of us and he said no,because he has a lot of work but probably wants to sleep until 12 or 2.
2 days ago a button of his coat ripped and I told him I'll sew it these days.
Earlier this morning while running late for his work,as always,he weara the coat and told him didn't get the chance to fix the button and sarcastically said..of.course u didn't!!!
I spent all night awake because one of the babies had congested nose and we've been trying to reduce one fees at night.
I wanted to punch him!!He left and I started crying...I cry so much,even at 5 months pp...
I can't go on like this anymoreeeee...
The crying in my ears is constant..my head is always numb..I've gained so much weight and can't find the strength to get back on track..
Even if I try to.find a therapist to just talk,is it gonna help?I really don't know😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

Avatar

8

Avoidant husband

I love my husband and he is a good man. We have some issues in our relationship however, as he has an avoidant attachment style (finds romance/intimacy/being emotional difficult). This comes from him having to be independent from a young age and having quite an abusive mother.
The issues in our relationship are mainly around a lack of sex and intimacy. I think the problem is that to feel turned on, I need to feel connected and wanted. My husband (being avoidant) will usually make jokes about being horny whereas I would want to have someone make me feel beautiful/sexy to get in the mood.
It sounds terrible but I've sometimes had dreams about exes that would make me feel this way, and the romance we had (eye contact, intensity, deep words). It makes me feel really guilty but I feel like i'm starved of that. My husband would like a lot more sex but I can't always force myself if I'm not feeling it.
We've spoken a bit about therapy but I know its often really expensive so we probably wouldn't be able to afford it. Do you have any suggestions please? I know that neither of us are wrong in what we want, just different but I'm scared about whether we can fix it or if we're doomed?

Avatar

12

If your partners parent passes away

And you and that parent didn't get along are you still go to the funeral?

Not my situation!

Avatar

14

Do you say "fruit" or "fruits"

Eg. I'm going to buy some ..........

Avatar

5

Read more on Peanut