Help! My daughter sees her 5 year old cousin on her phone(yes my brother got his 5 year old a real phone) and has been constantly asking my husband and I if she could have a 'real' phone. We have given her pretend ones that light up and make sounds and she recognizes its not a real working phone and asks for a real one. I didn't think I would be having this argument at 3. I didnt think she would ask for a phone until middle school. Idk what I was thinking. Any ideas on how to convince her she doesnt need one? I tried telling her things like "it will hurt your brain and eyes" "your eyes dont like it" and I redirect her to books, toys, slime, playdoh literally anything besides a phone. Any suggestions on how to deter her from wanting one?
Read more on PeanutThe views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.
Learn more about our guidelines.
She's 3, surely no means no is sufficient. I don't know why you're even arguing it out đ

Unfortunately this is going to be something that happens all throughout her childhood with different things other kids have. You have to in the end just say Iâve told you the reasons, you are not having one. I had the same with my kids about phones, Fortnite, Roblox, then social media. I always told them the reasons why and after that itâs a clear and firm I already said no and change the subject. Itâs hard because other parents will always allow things you wouldnât. My daughter recently told her educational support worker that Iâm a bad mum because I wonât let her out in the dark đ theyâll be times they think youâre so unfair, but I say itâs my job to keep you safe and sometimes you wonât like it x

I'm all for giving your kids reasons for your decisions, but if they keep asking, sometimes you just have to say "I said no"
If I'm bored of questions I also say "I'm not taking any more questions"

We gave our oldest (5) an old phone. It does have wifi because shes allowed to call family members on Google meets. But I control it through Family Link and have disabled 90% of the apps. She cannot go on Google or regular phone calls. We have Disney+ on there for when we are on the road. Like my youngest has therapy and at some points we have to sit in the vehicle for 1 1/2 hrs, so we play a movie/episodes that i saved on there.

She cant have one because in your family you have decided kids donât have phones until older. Hold space for her to be upset and explain that each family makes their own decisions hence her cousin having one.
I had a similar thing with my 4yo wanting water juice in his water bottle because someone at nursery has it. I mean, itâs called a water bottle because itâs for water, no juice đ but he finally got it

âIn our house children donât have phonesâ end of

Thatâs crazy your brother bought his 5yo a real phone đł He is really making a rod for his own back with that foolishness đ„Ž
I would just reiterate the word no and that sheâs too young. You could always try saying that her cousin is older and when she is that age, you will think about it just to stall/buy yourself some breathing space in the hopes she forgets.