in

Moms in their 30’s

How do you handle an overbearing MIL who can be kind but comments on everything?

My husband and I live in a four-bedroom house: our bedroom, his home office, the nursery, and a guest room. Our son is five months old, and I use the guest room to nurse him and sometimes sleep with him. My husband often works from our bed, taking calls or playing videos, and I prefer peace, quiet, and privacy while nursing.

I recently finished a really exhausting triple-feeding journey and have transitioned to almost exclusively breastfeeding. My baby still wakes at night, and this arrangement has helped me get more sleep and manage his feeds. Right now, protecting that progress is really important to me.

My MIL has been pressuring me to put him back in his crib and return to sleeping in the same room as my husband. Meanwhile, she keeps saying she wants to visit and doesn’t want to stay in a hotel. I feel like I’m being pushed to give up a space I’m using to care for my baby so she can stay over.

It’s also part of a bigger pattern. She comments on everything, from our pets to how she thinks I should give my baby more formula. I’m a stay-at-home mom and financially dependent on my husband right now, but I still want our parenting and household decisions to be respected.

When I decided to try daycare for a few hours, a few days a week, so I could go to the dentist, get my car serviced, and handle basic errands, she mentioned that her cleaning lady’s daughter sends her children to daycare. Maybe she meant it casually, but in context, it felt like a classist dig.

She also made comments about body odor while I was postpartum and breastfeeding, despite me showering daily. She suggested antibacterial soap and then bought us some. That felt embarrassing and intrusive at an already vulnerable time.

She can be generous, but the constant opinions and pressure are wearing me down. Am I being unreasonable for wanting her to stay in a hotel if we’re using the guest room? How would you set boundaries around visits and unsolicited comments without turning it into a huge conflict?

My husband is also very close with her and shares things I consider private. He told her about how I was stitched incorrectly after giving birth, along with other medical issues I’m not comfortable discussing with anyone. He even told her that I’d asked him for a push present. I feel extremely exposed, judged, and scrutinized, as though nothing in my life or marriage stays between us. Sometimes I wonder whether she’s trying to protect him from being taken advantage of, but I don’t know her intentions. What I do know is that I’m not comfortable with this level of intrusion, and I need my husband to respect my privacy.

My MIL has been pressuring me to put him back in his crib and return to sleeping in the same room as my husband. At the same time, she keeps saying she wants to visit but does not want to stay in a hotel. I feel as though I’m being expected to give up a space I’m using to care for my baby so she can stay overnight.

The larger issue is that my husband is not setting a clear limit with her. I am not comfortable hosting overnight visits right now, and even extended daytime visits are difficult because they disrupt our routine and leave me responsible for hosting while I’m caring for a five-month-old. I would be comfortable with visits for a few hours, but I need my husband to communicate and enforce that boundary rather than leaving me to negotiate with his mother.

There is also a pattern of unsolicited comments about our pets, feeding decisions, daycare, and my postpartum body. I understand that she may be lonely after losing her husband and that she is dealing with depression, but her circumstances do not make me responsible for providing overnight accommodations or accepting criticism. I want to be compassionate without allowing her needs to determine how we use our home or care for our baby.

Finances make the boundary problem more complicated. I’m a stay-at-home mom and financially dependent on my husband. He earns an income but asks me to go through his mother for large purchases and medical bills, citing a tax advantage. That means I’m expected to ask her for financial help while also trying to establish limits with her. It makes me feel as though her financial support gives her a role in decisions that should belong to my husband and me.

I need my husband to take responsibility for both parts of this problem: setting a firm limit that overnight visits are not available right now, and creating a financial arrangement that does not require me to depend directly on his mother or seek her approval. If her assistance is genuinely necessary, I think the terms should be clear, transparent, and agreed upon by both of us - not handled through private requests that make me feel indebted and undermine my ability to set boundaries.

I want my husband and me to make decisions about our home, our baby, visits, and finances together. His mother may be generous and may need support, but he is the person who needs to set limits with her. I should not have to choose between accepting financial help and tolerating pressure in my own home.

How would you handle this? How do I get my husband to take the lead in setting clear limits on visits and restructure the financial arrangement without turning it into a larger family conflict?