2.5 year old keeps hurting her baby sister.

How do I stop this. It doesn’t matter how much we try to tell her it’s wrong and punish her for it. She still carries on. My poor 9mo has got bruises all over her head from my 2.5 year old keeps throwing things at her and hitting her with anything she can find. I’ve contacted the Family support service and just waiting to hear back. I’m convinced she has behavioural issues. She never listens, constantly doing things she shouldn’t be doing and throws the worst tantrum and will hit, kick and throw things at me when she can’t get her own way. We tell her off for it but she just thinks it’s funny. If I put her in time out for doing wrong she will come out and do it again. I’m at my wits end. She goes to nursery and we always hear good things about her but when she’s around us it’s a different story.

Read more on Peanut

The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.

Learn more about our guidelines.
Add a comment
Avatar

Not had my own children yet, but a teacher and seen this alot with older siblings, it sounds like your 2.5 yr old is jealous and hasn't been able to process having a baby sister. My advice would be never to leave them alone together for now, and make sure your older daughter gets special attention, on her own, from both you and your partner or ither family members.
You may find that play therapy or other approaches which allow for the child to process and come to term with the change and the new expectations are helpful, family support should be able to tell you what's available in your Local authority, if not SENDIASS or the equivalent will.

Avatar

Have you tried involving her in helping with the baby, give her that special big sister role.

Doll role play give her real resources and demonstrate gentle touch and play.

I would in moments of calm use it as an opportunity to overpraise and have a group hug and announce it to dad how wonderful her behaviour was because ......and she gave baby big hugs.

It's a big thing having your parents to yourself then someone else takes over. As previously said set time aside for 1 on 1 time for your toddler.

There's loads of books that cover this subject for toddlers too.

Avatar

I don't have two but my understanding is that punishment/time outs aren't particularly effective especially at this age. I've found the book "how to talk so little kids will listen" quite helpful with various ideas for redirection, communication etc. I listened to the audiobook as struggle to find time to read, their voices are annoying 😂 but I've used some of the ideas and they work really well.

Just please don't follow the above suggestion of doing the same thing back to her 😬

Avatar

wow this is terrible advice! How can you tell a child that something is wrong if you then do it to them? Not to mention it’s literal child abuse!

Punishments and time out are pretty outdated methods now, sounds like she is struggling to adjust to baby. Carve out lots of one on one time with her when you can, demonstrate gentle hands and praise her lots when she is gentle and loving with baby. If she starts to hit or throw, remove her from the situation but sit with her and explain ‘I won’t allow you to hit/throw, I need to keep you both safe’ and wait with her, regulating until she calms down. It takes a lot of consistency but this approach does pay off (we had really similar behaviour with my 4 year old when he was 2.5). It’s a tricky age but will get better, there are some great books on authoritative parenting, Dr Becky’s ‘good inside’ is fantastic x

Avatar

hitting a child is child abuse, no 2 ways about it. What age exactly is ‘of age’?

Avatar

didn’t say to praise them for hitting? It’s about holding boundaries, removing them if they hit so they cannot continue, but remaining calm as you are the adult and the one in control of the situation. You cannot teach a child that hitting is wrong if you then hit them, that’s common sense. Fear based punishments just don’t work, all that happens is your child becomes scared of you and it totally breaks the trust in the relationship.

Avatar

the part of your brain responsible for decision making and understanding consequences doesn’t mature until 25yo.. a 2yo doesn’t know right from wrong, that’s what you have to teach them.

Not going to go back and forth with you as we clearly have 2 very different parenting styles, hopefully by the time your child is 2 you’ve had a change of heart.

Read more on Peanut

Trending

in our community

Is this clever or cruel?

My husband and i were talking and with social media and the internet in general being a terrifying dumpster fire, we are trying to figure out the best way to keep our son safe while still teaching him how to safely be online and moderation.

We landed on the idea of giving him the 90's kid treatment. A computer in the living room for us to keep an eye on what hes doing online, and once we feel hes mature enough to hang with friends without adult supervision he gets a flip phone. When we feel he is responsible enough and he earns and saves up the money for the physical phone, case, and screen cover, then we will be happy to take him to get a smart phone.

I thought this was air tight, but now my brother says its cruel to give a kid a flip phone, and besides he can just use his friends phones at school.

My husband and i remember a time before the internet, and we remember having complete access to something no one understood yet. We saw unspeakable things and are always battling with the urge to put the phone and social media down. I dont want that for my son, especially with his brain so vulnerable still.

Avatar

3

38

If your partners parent passes away

And you and that parent didn't get along are you still go to the funeral?

Not my situation!

Avatar

24

Partner no longer wants baby #2

Before our son was born we originally both wanted minimum 2 kids but we were hoping for 3-4. My partner found the birth traumatic to watch and also struggled a lot with the newborn/baby stage. He no longer wants to have any more children and it’s completely breaking my heart. I need another baby. We’ve spoken about it a lot and the options. He said he wasn’t COMPLETELY closed off to it so I asked him to try and work through his feelings and reconsider his decision. He eventually said he definitely doesn’t want another. I know that I will always want one and my feelings will never change. Do we have to break up or does anyone know anything else I can do to help change his mind? Has anyone else’s partner said this and then changed their mind? I don’t want to break up because I adore him and our life together and I’d hate to split up our family for “selfish” reasons and make my son miss out on having both of us together but I just don’t know what to do

Avatar

1

17

Nursery funding

My child turned 9 months last week. I applied for government funded hours nearly 2 months ago and so well within the required timeframe for the April term, however upon receiving my first invoice without the funding applied and having questioned this, I have now been informed that the stretched funding doesn’t start until 4th May.

Has anyone else been told it won’t start until May?

The government site states it should start from April 1st, and so I intentionally set my nursery start and return to work as the start of April for that reason, knowing that I wouldn’t be able to afford the nursery on my sole income without the funding

Avatar

6

Jealous of my husband

I’m so jealous of him and it’s making me resentful. We have a ten week old and I’m jealous that he is at work all day. I’m jealous he can leave for lunch and actually eat an uninterrupted lunch. Take a phone call uninterrupted. Chat with a friend he runs in to uninterrupted. Even go to the bathroom when he wants uninterrupted. He comes home from work when he wants. He’s not on a set schedule. Some days are late some are early. It depends on when he’s done. I’m jealous he can come home at 10pm and shower, eat and go right to bed uninterrupted because I already have the baby asleep. He doesn’t have to worry about anything house wise or baby wise because I’ve done it all. Meanwhile I’m covered in puke and crap and smell like rotten milk. When he is home he is VERY active and helpful. So it’s not that. I’m just jealous his world hasn’t changed and mine has I guess. This isn’t something he’s doing wrong so I’m not sure how to get past this. I wish I could keep him home all day because that’s how helpful he is, but I understand he obv needs to work.

Avatar

4

7

Calpol

My mum has just given my 4 year old calpol because he asked for it. He isn’t poorly (although was last week, been fine this week) he just likes the taste of it. My mum didn’t check, didn’t ask, just gave it to him and when I’ve questioned her she said “he asked for it”. Then quizzed 4 year old who said he asked for it because it tastes nice.

How would you react?

Avatar

4

Read more on Peanut