Gifted toddler - how to proceed?

Our son is 2.5 and everyone has been telling me that he's extremely gifted and that school will be a challenge because he'll be so bored. He can currently:
-Read independently, and knows how to sound out any unfamiliar words
-Count to 50 without help, 100 with help
-identify all basic colors and some niche ones like cyan, magenta
-write his name
-speak in full, descriptive sentences (he is a CHATTERBOX and a total social butterfly, no stranger danger here 😩)
-use the potty independently

However, he's still a toddler. He tantrums, he makes toddler decisions lol, he struggles with big feelings etc.

He is with me (or my mom) 24/7. He's never been to daycare. My question is, how essential is a formal school environment before 5? Should I continue to "homeschool" until kindergarten? Should I seek a Montessori or similar program to challenge him? Any guidance is helpful! He is currently the only child but I am trying for another.

Read more on Peanut

The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of Peanut.

Learn more about our guidelines.
Add a comment
Avatar

Does he understand the meaning of what he reads?

Also, did you teach him to count or did he more less learn it by himself?

Avatar

Can he count objects not just saying words? Or understand the words he’s reading and is able to recall events from the story?
Another thing that’s super important to learn is emotional regulation. Can he name his emotions/ why he is feeling a certain way?
As long as he’s getting interaction consistently with other children and can share/ work out problems/ play with other children then school isn’t necessary before 5 but those are the core important things to learn

Avatar

This was my child and I kept her home and homeschooled her until 5.5 and putting her in school (Montessori school) has matched her potential and even more, I do wish I was still homeschooling her but she has flourished so much and it was her choice to want to be around other kids more often then being home, and right now she’s the only kindergartener in her class so she has more ā€œresponsibilitiesā€ and she does great and it has helped her worked under pressure but she can decline on helping her peers more if she don’t want to

Avatar

he understands what he's reading and can recall events and also can describe something he read using different words. He also knows how to correct someone if they test his knowledge by telling him something that's wrong. He learned to count by himself after he got past 20 - he seemed to understand the pattern of the words. He can count objects specifically and again, will correct you if you count something wrong. He can name SOME emotions. He'll say he's frustrated when something isn't working but can't say that he's sad when he misses his grandma, for example.

Avatar

My daughter has hyperlexia. At 2.5 she knew about 60-70 flags and at almost 4 she’s reading everything she sees, writing and knows the directions on the tube network.

She goes to a Montessori nursery and she does thrive there but she also needs a lot of stimulation at home. Pre school work books on her play table, sensory activities, big walks at the park with I spy, trips to the library twice a week. She’s been in nursery since 11 months twice a week mainly for socialisation as we have no family or friends to play with.

It has been harder once I had baby 2 as she was bored at home with him so I kept up nursery as well as ballet class and softplay to burn her out. Also, she still needs a nap otherwise she starts throwing tantrums.

Avatar

Maybe he has a form of autism or another developmental skill this was one of the things that told me my daughter was autistic was behaviors

Avatar

He is certainly bright. Most of the things he can do sound within what is expected at his age, like naming colours (even cyan and magenta), descriptive sentences, being potty trained, etc.

I would keep note of all this and look for an assessment once he is a couple of years older.

Reading words and learning numbers independently or with little help at that age is called hyperlexia. Hyperlexia is more often a sign of neurodivergency than a sign of giftedness.

Being neurodivergent doesn't exclude being gifted, he could still be gifted. It would depend on other things.

Having no stranger danger is another red flag. Neurotypical children gravitate towards adults they are familiar with.

I wouldn't say homeschooling is best. It would be good to see how he does in groups with peers of his age. See how he manages conflicts and how he follows rules.

...

Avatar

Montessori is not the panacea. Some children get utterly bored, can't self-manage or don't thrive in Montessori. Some children do better in structured environments. You have to find what suits them best. You can only try to see.

In the meantime you could try getting informed on these traits and parenting strategies.

Avatar

I agree with Gia.
Most of the things you listed is normal for his age (I think where people get confused is when a child DOESNT do those things, they think they are behind, and when a child DOES all the things, they think they are gifted, when in reality, there’s a huge range and both are normal).
The only ā€œatypicalā€ thing you described is counting until 100 without help and like Gia said, sounds more like neurodivergency.

Avatar

He needs to develop social skills. Preschool really isnt about academics its about being with other children. Its a part of development. You can expose him
To other kids without preschool though.

Avatar

I'd be more apt to put him in a Montessori Preschool immediately & at age 4 apply to a charter or private school. My oldest recently tested above average in Kindergarten so I'm excited for the next parent teacher conferenceā¤ļø

Avatar

Can you speak to your health visitor? It sounds like whether it's neuro divergence or a natural ability they may be able to offer guidance and considerations. I'm amazed at the reading ability! My son is 3.5 and his development since starting nursery in October has been utterly bonkers. He also loves it and spending time with friends. If there's some neuro divergence there your child may not benefit from the social aspect of the setting in the same way or might appreciate a smaller setting. They're obviously very bright, have you asked them what they'd like, just out of curiosity? If you did home school there are so many groups now that you could tap into x

Avatar

I think this is normal? My daughter is the same

Avatar

autistic or not. I think you should expose him to pre school and see how he does. It won’t hurt and it will show you if he’s ready or not

Avatar

All kids, neurodivergent and neurotypical, need to develop social emotional skills and interact with other children.
By kindergarten at age 5, if your child has had only had limited social emotional peer experiences, it will be harder for them to develop it then. That’s the reason why pre-kindergarten schooling is an important step. It’s not just the academics but the engagement with peers and growing as individuals.

Read more on Peanut

Trending

in our community

Baby won’t be held

Quick question as a first time mum, is it normal for your baby to scream when being held by other people? My baby is 4 1/2 months old never had a problem being held by other people and it seems like overnight she will only be held by me and my husband if anyone else tries to hold her or pick her up including grandparents who she sees very regularly, she will just scream and cry and it takes me awhile to calm her down. I’m really hoping it’s just a phase but I don’t quite know what to do to get through it or if there’s anything I can do to be helping the situation it’s frustrating for us because it means we can’t hand her off to people to have a rest! but it’s also I’m sure frustrating for her grandparents who can’t hold her or have a cuddle with her. It also gets very awkward when they ask if they can hold her and all I want to say is no because I can see what’s about to happen…..

Avatar

3

Husband going on weekend away

Hi all, my husband is going on a weekend to France in a few weekends time to see his friend who lives there -Friday to Sunday. I’m really dreading it as our baby is just over 4 months and currently going through the regression and is super challenging at the moment. I’m so nervous to deal with it all on my own. I may go stay with his parents over the weekend or his sister may come see me for a night but I’m worried as my baby currently screams and melts down if held by anyone but me . I don’t want to be super negative and want my husband to enjoy his weekend but I feel so anxious and stressed . I don’t know whether to have his sister come stay with me for a night or go to his parents a 1 hour drive away to get a break …. As I said her current state means none of them will actually be able to help me as she only wants me ! If I go to his parents I get a change of scenery and have some support but am in a less familiar environment and plus she hates that car!! If I stay home then I’m in a comfortable environment and I’m n my own space but will only have his sister for support for one evening not his whole family …… Any advice ?

Avatar

3

Moving on

Recently I've come to the decision to no longer allow certain behaviors that are for adults and children. Without trauma dumping, My son and I are in a recovery period. No one in our lives understand that. It's always get over it and you're still held up on it. When "it" wasn't over until November of last year. Through protection orders and not really having any guidance or village when it comes to us, I'm definitely paving the way for our outcome to be bigger than our downfall was. No one knows yet, but we are moving away from everyone we know and everything we know. Somewhere where we can start fresh and continue. We're not running and that's all everyone is going to see it as. I have my baby's childhood in my hands and I'm determined to make it as good as I can before he's older. I don't know if/when we will tell everyone where we are but for now I know and understand that we need to get right and start new.

Avatar

6

5

Excuse

Would it bother anyone else??🤣🤣🄲
My mil and sil, at their own fault, had to drop something over to our house the other day before they went to work, for my partner. Due to this, they were 5 mins late for their shift. Instead of just making up an excuse like there was traffic, they told their boss that they had to rush over to our house because my little one had hit her head and was injured, which was very much not the case!🤣why say that? Weird behaviour, right?🤣🤨they thought it was funny as they told me the next time I saw them. I think this is a regular thing, I know they’ve used excuses from our little one for work things before.
Bearing in mind, they make no effort with her/us, so them helping with anything isn’t in the picture anyways.
Happy Sunday yallšŸ¤£šŸ˜…

Avatar

5

Feeling deflated at the start of weaning

My nearly 7 month old just started weaning 5 days ago. First 3 days gave her broccoli. She loved it, first 2 days she had 2 spoons, and 3rd day about 10 spoons! Yesterday I started on butternut squash and she didn’t look amused but had a spoon or 2 forcefully, then today she also had butternut squash but was forced she had one spoon then every spoon I tried after that she didn’t want it. Is this strange considering she liked the broccoli but the butternut squash is more sweet and yummy I thought she would have enjoyed it. I mixed both with my breast milk.

Avatar

10

Am I overreacting

Long story short my partner and I only get one day together every week which is a Sunday. He looks after our girl on Mondays while I work and then he is working the rest of the week (long hours and not home until 10.30pm most nights)

Last Sunday he went fishing all day Sunday, last night he sprung it on me he was coming with me today to a party as he’s going fishing again (left 3.30am and said he will be back for 2pm) it’s now almost 4pm and he’s still not back and I’ve not seen him since yesterday morning briefly before he left for work.

Next Sunday he is out again all day fishing with his mate.

At the moment I am extremely run down with a chest infection and just feeling like I’m being pushed to one side. I understand he wants to be able to do his own things too on his day off but I’m starting to lose my patience because I am so exhausted and the thought of waiting 3 more weeks until I can have any sort of ā€˜rest’ is killing me.

I don’t think he is taking my feelings or needs into consideration but perhaps I am being selfish in wanting a rest? It’s not helping that our girl is so full on at the moment (22 months) who also has a chest infection and going through a sleep regression waking multiple times a night 😩 I am exhausted

Avatar

6

Read more on Peanut